Appealing a Departmental decision. Independent merits review for visa refusals and cancellations.
A refused or cancelled decision is devastating, especially when the decision by a case officer seems unfair or wrongly made. Fortunately, reviewable decisions fall under the jurisdiction of the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) for merits review.
The ART operates independently from the Department and looks at your application afresh, examining all the facts, evidence, and law relevant to your matter. Decisions made by the ART are published to ensure transparency and accountability in migration decision making.
Timeframes for applying to the ART are strict and inflexible and missing a deadline can permanently remove your right to review. Departmental decisions (other than those made under section 501 and section 501CA) generally provide for 28 days to apply for appeal. The ART does not provide discretions to extend application deadlines. If you are unsure when your timeframe expires, contact us immediately.
The Administrative Review Tribunal has the power to:
The Department’s decision (agree with it).
The decision (change part of it).
Substitute a new decision (make a different decision).
The matter to the Department for reconsideration with specific directions.
The right to seek review depends on the type of decision. Most decisions made by the Department under the Migration Act 1958 can be reviewed, including:
Note: Decisions made personally by the Minister for Immigration or those involving national security matters may not be reviewable by the ART.
An application for review with the ART is often a vital opportunity to correct an unfair or incorrect decision.
We start by reviewing your decision notice, identifying which provisions of the Migration Act 1958 were applied, and identifying potential legal errors in judgement.
We then assess your grounds for appeal and determine whether new evidence can strengthen your case. Our first goal is clarity.
The ART allows the submission of new material not previously available. This is an excellent opportunity to gather new evidence to support your case.
We ensure the comprehensive legal submission is structured for readability and persuasiveness and formatted for maximum impact.
Benefits of Review: Clarify errors, provide new/updated evidence, explain personal/health/family circumstances that warrant compassion, and ensure your case is assessed independently and fairly.
Wintr Consulting acknowledges the traditional owners of country throughout Australia and acknowledges their continuing connection to land, waters, and community. We pay our respects to the people, the cultures, and the elders past and present.
Copyright © 2025 Wintr Consulting. All rights reserved.